Why is Toledo so cheap? Population loss, lower incomes, older homes and high taxes kept...
Read More
"What's the cap rate in Toledo?" is the first question most investors ask, and it has no single answer. Toledo cap rates run from under 3% in the city's priciest ZIP codes to well over 10% in its cheapest, and the "15% cap rate" you'll see on some listings almost never survives a real repair budget. This guide breaks down Toledo cap rates by ZIP code, by property type and by neighborhood class, using September 2026 sales data and HUD's 2027 rent figures. It also covers the change most investors haven't priced in yet: with mortgage rates above 7%, a financed rental now needs a higher cap rate just to break even.
The short answer
Most Toledo cap rates for single-family rentals fall between about 4% and 11%, depending on price and location. Houses at or above the city's $154,926 median typically produce 3% to 7%; houses bought under $100,000 can produce 9% to 11% after a realistic repair budget. Duplexes often land around 8% to 10%, and larger apartment buildings trade at about 4.7% to 5.7%. At today's 7.32% mortgage rate, a 30-year loan costs about 8.2% a year in principal and interest, so you need roughly an 8% cap rate or better for financing to add to your cash flow instead of eating it.
4%–11%
Typical single-family cap rate range in Toledo, after realistic expenses
Our calculation, Oct. 2026
~9%
Cap rate on a typical Toledo duplex at the $110,000 median list price
Our calculation from Redfin listings
8.24%
Annual loan constant on a 30-year loan at 7.32%
Freddie Mac rate, Oct. 22, 2026
4.7%–5.7%
Cap rates on Toledo apartment buildings (5+ units)
Apartment Loan Store, Oct. 2026
How We Calculated Toledo Cap Rates
A cap rate is a property's net operating income (NOI) divided by its price. NOI is rent minus every operating cost except the mortgage. The math is simple; the inputs are where most online cap rates go wrong, usually by leaving out vacancy, repairs or Toledo's property taxes. Every number in this guide uses the same inputs:
| Input | Assumption | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase price | Redfin median sale price by ZIP, 3 months ending Sept. 2026 | What houses actually sold for, not list prices |
| Rent | 90% of HUD's FY2027 Small Area Fair Market Rent for a 3-bedroom | A ZIP-level rent benchmark; 90% is HUD's lowest payment standard, a conservative proxy for market rent |
| Property tax | 2.0% of price per year | Effective rate for a rental in the Toledo City School District (2025 rates) |
| Insurance | $1,000 to $1,500 a year, by price | Typical landlord policy range |
| Management | 9% of collected rent | Middle of Toledo's 8% to 10% range |
| Vacancy and collection loss | 5% (8% for homes under $100,000) | Lower-priced areas turn over more often |
| Repairs and capital reserves | 10% of rent (15% under $100,000) | Toledo's housing stock is old; cheaper homes need more |
Your actual cap rate depends on the specific house, its tax bill and its real rent. Our Toledo ROI calculator lets you plug in your own numbers.
Toledo Cap Rates by ZIP Code
| ZIP | Median sale price | Price change YoY | Est. 3-bed rent | Gross yield | Cap rate at median price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 43608 | $50,000 | −0.5% | $1,197 | 28.7% | 15.7%* |
| 43610 | $55,000 | +37.5% | $1,314 | 28.7% | 15.9%* |
| 43609 | $76,000 | +8.5% | $1,323 | 20.9% | 11.0%* |
| 43605 | $84,000 | +28.7% | $1,332 | 19.0% | 9.9%* |
| 43607 | $113,000 | −2.0% | $1,242 | 13.2% | 7.0% |
| 43612 | $129,000 | +4.4% | $1,386 | 12.9% | 6.9% |
| 43611 | $170,000 | +9.6% | $1,260 | 8.9% | 4.1% |
| 43613 | $170,000 | +5.4% | $1,287 | 9.1% | 4.2% |
| 43615 | $210,000 | +7.5% | $1,494 | 8.5% | 3.8% |
| 43614 | $212,000 | +2.9% | $1,233 | 7.0% | 2.6% |
| 43606 | $225,000 | −4.3% | $1,341 | 7.2% | 2.8% |
| 43623 | $231,000 | −3.7% | $1,314 | 6.8% | 2.6% |
| 43617 | $359,000 | +14.8% | $1,503 | 5.0% | 1.4% |
Sources: Redfin ZIP-code housing-market pages (median sale price, all home types, three months ending September 2026); HUD FY2027 Small Area Fair Market Rents (3-bedroom, 90% payment standard). Expenses as listed above. *Medians in these ZIPs are pulled down by houses that need major work; see the reality check below.
Three patterns stand out in the Toledo cap rate data:
- Rent barely changes; price changes a lot. HUD's 3-bedroom rent benchmark ranges only from about $1,200 to $1,500 across these ZIP codes, while median prices range from $50,000 to $359,000. That's why Toledo cap rates are driven almost entirely by what you pay.
- The middle of the market is where financed deals are thinnest. In 43611, 43613, 43614 and 43623, median-priced homes produce cap rates of 2.6% to 4.2%. Those areas suit owner-occupants and appreciation-focused cash buyers, not leveraged cash flow. The same is true in most of the Toledo suburbs.
- The sweet spot is in between. 43607 and 43612 show cap rates near 7% at the median, and buying 10% to 20% below the median in those areas is how many Toledo investors reach 8% to 9%. See our best ZIP codes for rental investment in Toledo for more on each area.
The "15% Cap Rate" Reality Check
Those 15% to 16% cap rates in 43608 and 43610 are real math on paper. They're not what most investors actually earn. A $50,000 median in a Toledo ZIP code usually means a lot of the houses that sold needed a roof, a furnace, windows, electrical updates or lead-safe work before anyone could rent them. Here's the same 43608 house with a rehab budget added:
| On paper | With a realistic rehab | |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase price | $50,000 | $50,000 |
| Rehab, lead-safe work and holding costs | $0 | $35,000 |
| Total cost | $50,000 | $85,000 |
| Net operating income | $7,871 | $7,871 |
| Cap rate | 15.7% | 9.3% |
A 9% cap rate on a fully renovated house is still a strong Toledo deal. But if you underwrite at 15% and get 9%, every other number in your plan is wrong. Lower-priced areas also carry more vacancy, more turnover and more management time than any spreadsheet shows. When a listing advertises a double-digit cap rate, ask what's been fixed, what hasn't, and what the actual rent roll and tax bill are.
Toledo Cap Rates by Property Type
| Property type | Typical Toledo cap rate | What drives it |
|---|---|---|
| Single-family, at or above median price | 3% to 7% | Priced by owner-occupant demand, not rent |
| Single-family, under $100,000 after rehab | 8% to 11% | Low price, solid rent; more repairs and turnover |
| Duplex (2 units) | 8% to 10% | Two rents on one roof, one tax bill; owner often pays water |
| 3 to 4 units | 8% to 10% | Similar to duplexes; fewer buyers, so better prices |
| Apartment buildings (5+ units) | 4.7% to 5.7% | Commercial financing and institutional buyers bid prices up |
Single-family and duplex ranges are our calculations from the ZIP data above and current listings. Apartment range: Apartment Loan Store Toledo survey, October 2026 (metro 4.7%–5.6%, suburban 4.8%–5.7%), a rough benchmark with undisclosed methodology.
A real Toledo duplex example. In October 2026, Redfin showed 109 multifamily listings in Toledo. Among the typical side-by-side and up-down duplexes (two units, four bedrooms total), the median list price was about $110,000. One listing in 43607 at that price had units renting for $810 and $825, tenants paying gas and electric, and the owner paying water and sewer. Here's how a duplex like that underwrites at $875 per unit:
| Line | Annual amount |
|---|---|
| Gross rent (2 × $875 × 12) | $21,000 |
| Vacancy and collection loss (7%) | −$1,470 |
| Management (9%) | −$1,758 |
| Property tax (2%) | −$2,200 |
| Insurance | −$1,600 |
| Water and sewer (owner-paid) | −$1,500 |
| Repairs and reserves (12%) | −$2,520 |
| Net operating income | $9,952 |
| Cap rate at $110,000 | 9.0% |
That's why duplexes are a favorite for Toledo investors who finance: they're one of the few property types that clear today's borrowing cost. Our guide to single-family vs. multifamily investing in Toledo covers the trade-offs in management and resale. If you're financing one, see how DSCR loans in Ohio are sized off the rent.
Cap Rates by Neighborhood Class
Investors often describe Toledo areas by class, A through D. Class describes property condition, market dynamics and risk, never the people who live there, and it can change within a few blocks. These are the working ranges we use when we underwrite:
| Class | Typical cap rate | What you're trading |
|---|---|---|
| A | 3% to 5% | Low maintenance, long tenancies, stronger appreciation; little cash flow with a loan |
| B | 5% to 8% | Balanced; the best fit for most first-time and out-of-state investors |
| C | 8% to 11% | Strong cash flow with active management and real repair budgets |
| D | 12%+ on paper | Highest turnover, collection and vacancy risk; actual returns often far below the paper number |
Working ranges based on our underwriting, consistent with the ZIP-level calculations above. Assess class at the property and block level. See Toledo neighborhood classes for investors.
Why 7% Mortgage Rates Change the Math
Here's the part most Toledo cap rate articles skip. When you borrow, your mortgage has its own "cap rate," called the loan constant: the yearly principal and interest payment divided by the loan amount. At the October 22, 2026 Freddie Mac average of 7.32% on a 30-year loan, the loan constant is about 8.24%.
- If the property's cap rate is above 8.24%, borrowing increases your return on cash (positive leverage).
- If it's below 8.24%, borrowing reduces your return (negative leverage).
| Cap rate | Yearly cash flow after the mortgage | Cash-on-cash return | DSCR |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6% | −$182 | −0.7% | 0.97 |
| 7% | $818 | 2.9% | 1.13 |
| 8% | $1,818 | 6.5% | 1.29 |
| 9% | $2,818 | 10.1% | 1.46 |
| 10% | $3,818 | 13.6% | 1.62 |
$100,000 purchase, 25% down plus 3% closing costs ($28,000 cash), $75,000 30-year loan at 7.32% ($6,182 a year in principal and interest). DSCR = NOI ÷ annual debt payment; most DSCR lenders want 1.0 to 1.25 or higher.
A year ago, at 6.19%, the loan constant was about 7.34%, so a Toledo rental at a 7.5% cap rate still had positive leverage. At 7.32%, that same house barely pays for itself with 25% down. If you're financing, either buy at 8% or better, put more money down, or accept that you're buying for appreciation and principal paydown rather than monthly cash flow. Cash buyers can accept lower cap rates in stronger areas.
Want the Real Cap Rate on a Toledo Property?
Send Austin the address. He'll underwrite it with the actual tax bill, real rent comps, a repair budget for that house, and today's financing, so you see the cap rate and cash flow before you make an offer.
Get a Deal UnderwrittenNo pressure. No obligation.
Toledo vs. Other Ohio Cities
| City | Median sale price (Sept. 2026) | HUD 3-bed Fair Market Rent (FY2027) | Gross yield |
|---|---|---|---|
| Toledo | $154,926 | $1,461 | 11.3% |
| Cleveland | $150,000 | $1,628 | 13.0% |
| Cincinnati | $280,000 | $1,897 | 8.1% |
| Columbus | $299,000 | $1,909 | 7.7% |
Sources: Redfin city pages (three months ending September 2026); HUD FY2027 Fair Market Rents for each metro area. Gross yield = annual 3-bedroom FMR ÷ city median price; a before-expenses screen, not a cap rate.
Toledo and Cleveland are in the same tier: low entry prices and high gross yields. Columbus and Cincinnati cost nearly twice as much, with yields that make cash flow hard at today's rates, so investors there are betting more on appreciation. If you're also weighing markets outside Ohio, our Toledo vs. Indianapolis vs. Memphis comparison runs the same kind of math.
What Cap Rate Should You Target in Toledo?
- Financing with 20% to 25% down: target 8.5% or better on your all-in cost (price plus rehab). That clears today's 8.24% loan constant with a margin for surprises.
- Buying with cash for income: 8% to 10% in B and C areas is a realistic, repeatable target with good management.
- Buying with cash for stability or appreciation: 5% to 7% in A and B areas can make sense if you value low turnover and long-term growth over monthly cash flow.
- Anything advertised above 12%: treat it as a starting point for questions, not a return. Rebuild the number with a real repair budget and an actual tax bill.
Two things could push Toledo cap rates around in 2027. Prices are still rising (see our Toledo housing market update), which pushes cap rates down if rents don't keep up. And property taxes on rentals are rising as Ohio's House Bill 186 phases out the 10% non-business credit through 2029, which trims NOI by a little each year. Details are in our Lucas County property tax guide.
FAQ
What is a good cap rate in Toledo, Ohio?
For a financed rental in 2026, a good Toledo cap rate is about 8.5% or higher on your total cost, because a 30-year loan at 7.32% costs about 8.24% a year in principal and interest. Cash buyers focused on income often target 8% to 10%, while cash buyers in stronger areas may accept 5% to 7% for lower risk and better appreciation.
What is the average cap rate in Toledo?
There isn't one meaningful average, because Toledo cap rates vary so much by price. Using September 2026 sales data and HUD rents, single-family cap rates at the median price range from about 2.6% in higher-priced ZIP codes to around 7% in mid-priced ones, and 9% to 11% for lower-priced homes after a realistic rehab. Duplexes often land around 8% to 10%.
Why are cap rates higher in Toledo than in most U.S. cities?
Toledo home prices are about 62% below the U.S. median, while rents are only moderately lower. Because rent is high relative to price, net income is high relative to price, which means higher cap rates. Part of that higher return also reflects more risk: older housing, higher repair costs and more turnover in lower-priced areas.
How do mortgage rates affect Toledo cap rates?
Mortgage rates don't change a property's cap rate, but they change whether the cap rate is good enough. At 7.32%, a 30-year loan costs about 8.24% a year. A rental with a cap rate below that produces less cash flow when financed than when bought with cash. That's why many Toledo investors now target 8.5% or higher.
What is the difference between cap rate and cash-on-cash return?
Cap rate measures a property's net income against its price, ignoring financing. Cash-on-cash return measures your yearly cash flow after the mortgage against the cash you actually invested. For example, a $100,000 Toledo rental at a 9% cap rate with 25% down at 7.32% produces about a 10% cash-on-cash return.
What are cap rates for apartment buildings in Toledo?
Larger Toledo apartment buildings with five or more units trade at lower cap rates than houses, about 4.7% to 5.7% according to an October 2026 survey by Apartment Loan Store. They attract commercial lenders and institutional buyers, which pushes prices up. Duplexes and 3–4 unit buildings usually offer higher cap rates, often 8% to 10%.
Cap rates are a starting point, not a decision. The right Toledo deal depends on the house, the block, the real tax bill and how you plan to finance it. Austin underwrites Toledo rentals every week for local and out-of-state investors and can tell you quickly whether a number holds up. Learn more on our Is Toledo a good place to invest? guide.
Talk to Austin About a Toledo Deal
Disclaimer: Cap rates and returns in this article are estimates based on public data and stated assumptions as of October 2026. They aren't guarantees or investment advice. Every property is different; confirm rents, taxes, insurance and repair costs for any specific deal.
Sources reviewed for this guide (October 2026)
- Redfin: Toledo, OH housing market and ZIP-code pages (43605–43623)
- Redfin: Toledo multifamily listings (October 2026)
- HUD: FY2027 Small Area Fair Market Rents
- HUD: FY2027 Fair Market Rents (Toledo, Cleveland, Columbus, Cincinnati)
- Freddie Mac 30-year fixed mortgage rate (FRED)
- Lucas County Auditor: 2025 effective tax rates
- Apartment Loan Store: Toledo apartment cap rates (October 2026)
- Redfin: Cleveland, Columbus and Cincinnati housing markets